Amazon Basics 50L Trash Can Review: Is the $74 Price Tag Worth It?

Deep dive into the Amazon Basics 50L trash can vs Simplehuman comparison — which one actually delivers value at $74?

This article contains affiliate links. Purchases may earn me a small commission at no extra cost to you.

TL;DR — The Quick Verdict

If you're in a hurry, here it is:

• Renters / average households: Go with the Amazon Basics 50L (B07PCXYSY8), $74, 45,849 reviews, smudge-resistant stainless steel — best value for the price
• Silence-obsessive / long-term thinkers: Spend the extra $36+ on the Simplehuman (B095XG9VSN), near-silent lid, 10-year bearing life
• Don't buy under 50L: For kitchen use, 13.2 gallons (50L) is the bare minimum — anything smaller and you'll be taking out trash daily

In three sentences: Amazon Basics gets the job done cheaply. Simplehuman is quieter and more durable but costs nearly double. If you just need "a working trash can," Amazon Basics; if you open it 50+ times a day, Simplehuman.

Real Price Comparison (May 2026)

Product	Price	Reviews	Rating	Material
Amazon Basics 50L	~$74	45,849	4.4/5	Smudge-resistant stainless steel
Simplehuman 50L	~$110+	10,000+	4.7/5	Stainless steel + patented silent

Prices as of publishing date — check current pricing before purchase.

Design & Build Quality

Amazon Basics: Rectangular shape, brushed nickel finish, smudge-resistant coating — the most practical kitchen feature you'll find on a trash can. 16.7×14.7×25.9 inches, 50L capacity, fits comfortably under most kitchen cabinets.

Simplehuman: Semi-round design, same brushed finish, slightly smaller footprint but comparable internal capacity. Simplehuman's design reads more "professional kitchen" — sharper lines. Amazon Basics feels softer and more residential.

Both use pedal openers: Amazon Basics pedal requires slightly more force, Simplehuman's patented ShoX technology provides a noticeably smoother press.

Capacity & Real-World Use

50L (13.2 gallons) is the sweet spot for home trash cans:

• Family of 3: takes about 3-4 days to fill
• Two people sharing: a full week is completely doable
• Small kitchen: won't eat up too much floor space

Amazon Basics' hidden win: the inner bucket is removable with handles, making bag changes easier than Simplehuman. Simplehuman's bucket is friction-fitted — you need to really pull to get it out.

Noise & Durability

This is where the two really diverge:

Amazon Basics: Soft-close lid but a distinct "clunk" on open/close. Pedal requires more force — fatigue builds over months of use. Steel bearings are standard; expect squeaking after 3-5 years.

Simplehuman: Patented Silent Close lid — near-zero noise on operation, pedal resistance is perfectly tuned. Better bearing quality throughout; company rates it for 10 years, real users report 8-10 years of silent operation.

TechGearLab's verdict: Amazon Basics is "around half the cost of some of its competitors (like the popular Simplehuman)" — but core functionality gap is minimal.

Who Should Buy Which

Go Amazon Basics if you:

• Prioritize budget, $74 works for you
• Medium kitchen use (under 20 opens/day)
• Renting and can't justify bigger investment
• Don't mind the occasional clunk

Go Simplehuman if you:

• Willing to pay extra for silence (+$36)
• Heavy use (50+ opens/day)
• Long-term thinker, planning 8-10 years of use
• Zero tolerance for kitchen noise

Purchase Recommendation

Most practical pick: Amazon Basics 50L B07PCXYSY8, $74, solid for 3-5 years. Grab a pack of Amazon Basics trash bags (Code G for 50L), ~$10 for 20 bags.

If budget allows: Simplehuman B095XG9VSN is a long-term investment — $110+ buys you a decade of quiet mornings.

Don't: Anything below 12L. Kitchen trash volume surprises everyone. Buy small, regret daily.

👉 Check Amazon Basics 50L Trash Can: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PCXYSY8?tag=techpassive-20

---

Also Recommended:

Product	Link
Amazon Basics 50L Trash Can	View on Amazon
Amazon Basics Kitchen Trash Bags	View on Amazon
Simplehuman 50L Trash Can	View on Amazon

📌 This article was AI-assisted generated and human-reviewed | TechPassive — An AI-driven content testing site focused on real tool reviews