Santen FX: What 2nd Class and 3rd Class Actually Mean
TL;DR:The 第2類 / 第3類 label on a Japanese eye drop is a risk tier, not a strength rating, so "3rd class means weaker" is wrong by definition. Of the four Santen FX bottles, only サンテFX コンタクト sits in 第3類, and it is the only one whose official 効能・効果 section lists soft contact lens wear as an indication. Prices I pulled from Amazon.co.jp on 5 Nov 2026 were ¥924 for Vプラス 12mL, ¥1,473 for AL 12mL ×2 and ¥1,680 for コンタクト 12mL ×6. Hard lenses plus maximum chill: Vプラス. Itchy, seasonal allergy eyes: AL. Soft lenses: コンタクト is the only answer in the lineup.
I pulled all four official product pages one by one and then opened each live Amazon.co.jp listing to check the title and the price. The more I compared, the clearer one thing became: almost every English or Chinese write-up on Japanese eye drops stops at "how many stars of chill", while the field this labelling system actually uses for decisions is not chill at all.
One boundary first. This article reads labels and ingredient tables; it is not medical advice. Eye drops are drugs — if you have inflammation, pain or vision changes, see an ophthalmologist. The links below are affiliate links and I earn a commission from them, so that is stated up front rather than buried.
I have worked through this labelling style before on this site, with Japanese sunscreen and the SPF/PA scale and with anti-fog coating tiers on Japanese swim goggles. Same method every time: find out what the Japanese label itself says before choosing a product. Eye drops go further than either, because the fields here are legally mandated.
2nd class and 3rd class are risk tiers, not strength tiers
Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare defines the three OTC tiers in its policy paper on the 2009 revision of the OTC sales system. The wording is worth reading literally:
- 第一類医薬品: contains ingredients requiring particular caution for safety, such as those with little history of OTC use
- 第二類医薬品: contains ingredients that could rarely cause health damage serious enough to require hospitalisation
- 第三類医薬品: contains ingredients that could cause bodily discomfort, though not to the point of disrupting daily life
Look at the phrasing in the second line: "rarely, hospitalisation-level". The third line is "not enough to disrupt daily life, but discomfort is possible". The whole definition talks about risk. Not one word about how well the product works.
There is a second, more practical difference attached to it — the duty to explain at the point of sale. Class 1 must be explained by a pharmacist using written material. Class 2 requires a pharmacist or registered seller to make an effort to provide information. Class 3 requires no explanation at sale at all; the seller only has to answer if the customer asks.
That single rule explains something concrete. Pick up a class-3 eye drop in a Japanese drugstore and nobody is obliged to tell you anything about it. The thinnest, most contradictory coverage of FX コンタクト in Chinese-language guides is a direct consequence: politically it falls into the "no explanation required" bucket, so the information never gets generated in the first place.
To know if you can dose with lenses in, read the indications, not the icon
Santen's brand page prints an icon per bottle: コンタクトレンズ対応 ハード◯ / ソフト×. The icon is easy, but it is second-hand information. The primary source is the 効能・効果 (indications) block on each product page, which states the legally approved scope:
- サンテFX Vプラス: …discomfort while wearing hard contact lenses
- サンテFX ネオ: …discomfort while wearing hard contact lenses
- サンテFX コンタクト: …discomfort while wearing soft or hard contact lenses
- サンテFX AL: no contact-lens item anywhere in its indications
The pattern is exact. A ◯ on the icon corresponds to the presence of the line "discomfort while wearing contact lenses" in the indications. Vプラス and ネオ say hard only, so soft is ×. コンタクト says soft or hard, so it is the only double ◯ in the lineup. AL omits the line entirely, so both are ×.
This reading rule outlives any specific model. When Santen ships something new, you find that line on the detail page and decide for yourself instead of waiting for a guide to be updated.
One prohibition is easy to miss. The コンタクト product page carries a footnote after the product name — "カラーコンタクトレンズは除く" — and the brand overview page states it more bluntly: do not use while wearing colour contact lenses. So for anyone wearing circle lenses or coloured contacts, all four FX bottles are out. Almost none of the Chinese-language summaries I read mention this, yet it is printed by the manufacturer.
The four ingredient lists: 7, 5 and 4 actives
Copying the active ingredients from the official pages makes the difference obvious. Ingredients and concentrations below are taken verbatim from Santen's product pages; percentages are the share in the formulation:
| Ingredient | FX ネオ | FX Vプラス | FX AL | FX コンタクト |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine hydrochloride) | — | 0.1% | — | — |
| Panthenol | — | — | — | 0.1% |
| Taurine | 1.0% | 1.0% | 1.0% | 1.0% |
| Potassium L-aspartate | 1.0% | 1.0% | 1.0% | 1.0% |
| Neostigmine methylsulfate | 0.005% | 0.005% | — | — |
| Tetrahydrozoline hydrochloride | 0.05% | 0.05% | — | — |
| Chlorpheniramine maleate | 0.03% | 0.03% | 0.03% | — |
| Sodium cromoglicate | — | — | 1.0% | — |
| Epsilon-aminocaproic acid | 1.0% | 1.0% | 1.0% | 1.0% |
| Risk tier | 2nd | 2nd | 2nd | 3rd |
Count the actives: ネオ has 6, Vプラス has 7, AL has 5, コンタクト has 4.
Two of those names deserve their own paragraph. Tetrahydrozoline hydrochloride is a vasoconstrictor; it is what removes the red from the white of the eye. The redness goes away, but only temporarily, and this is the single most abused ingredient class in combination eye drops. Neostigmine methylsulfate is an anticholinesterase acting on ciliary muscle accommodation; the official wording is that it improves eye strain through a focus-adjustment effect.
Now see where those two land: present in Vプラス and ネオ, absent from AL, absent from コンタクト.
Which is why the class-3 bottle makes sense once you read its list. コンタクト is the only one in the lineup that drops the vasoconstrictor, the antihistamine and the anticholinesterase all at once, keeping just two metabolic amino acids (taurine, potassium L-aspartate), one vitamin (panthenol) and one anti-inflammatory (epsilon-aminocaproic acid).
So "3rd class" and "4 ingredients" are two independent clues pointing the same way: the tier is low because the formula is conservative, not because the effect was discounted. AL shows the same logic from the other side — as the allergy bottle it swaps in sodium cromoglicate 1.0% and drops the vasoconstrictor route too.
One observation, offered as an observation because Santen does not explain it: the additive lists for Vプラス and AL both contain benzalkonium chloride, while コンタクト uses chlorhexidine gluconate instead. That difference lines up exactly with the "soft lenses can only use コンタクト" conclusion, but the manufacturer never states causation. I will not invent it for them. You just need to know the two facts sit on the same page.
The "5+" chill rating is an in-house scale
The chill ratings are ネオ 5, Vプラス 5+, AL 5+, コンタクト 5. The caption under the scale reads: the larger the number, the stronger the refreshing sensation; the smaller, the gentler on the eye.
The plus sign is the point. The 5+ on Vプラス and AL carries a footnote reading 当社製品内で最も高い清涼感レベル — the highest chill level within our own products, not the highest on the market.
That footnote sinks claims like "FX is the chilliest eye drop there is". It tops Santen's own range and nothing else. There is no cross-brand scale, and the sensation is as subjective as the cooling in a shampoo. Buy the 5+ expecting the industry maximum and you have bought Santen's internal first place.
The more informative detail is that コンタクト still rates 5. The soft-lens bottle was not dialled down to something bland; it stays at the upper-middle of the same series. That contradicts the common assumption that anything lens-safe must be gentle to the point of doing nothing.
The dose ceiling on AL is lower than on Vプラス
Dosing is not one set of numbers across the four:
| Product | Per dose | Per day |
|---|---|---|
| FX ネオ | 2–3 drops | 5–6 times |
| FX Vプラス | 2–3 drops | 5–6 times |
| FX AL | 1–2 drops | 4–6 times |
| FX コンタクト | 1–3 drops | 5–6 times |
AL has the lowest ceiling — 1–2 drops, 4–6 times a day. It is the antihistamine bottle, containing chlorpheniramine, so the dose ceiling is pressed down further. "My eyes itch, I'll add two more drops" is an overdose on AL.
Here I have to point out a place where the official site contradicts itself, because it is a textbook case of the problem. On the サンテFX AL detail page, the 効果・効能 / 用法・用量 table says 1回1~2滴、1日4~6回. A duplicated text block lower on the same page says 1回2~3滴、1日5~6回. Same URL, different numbers. The brand overview page gives 1–2 drops and 4–6 times, matching the table, so the stricter set is the one to follow — but a reader who copies the duplicated block is over the limit. This is why you check the page itself rather than a translation of it.
Santen's own "how to use eye drops" page adds a number worth knowing: fewer than half of people instil drops correctly (正しく点眼できている人は半分以下ともいわれています). The basic motion is to pull the lower lid down and place one drop reliably, then close the eye without blinking for one to five minutes, or press a fingertip against the inner corner near the nose. So the 2–3 drop figure in the dosing column is a ceiling. One drop is enough in practice — the rest drains down the nasolacrimal duct and can increase systemic absorption.
Three checks before you order on Amazon.co.jp
First, read the bracketed prefix in the listing title. Japanese OTC listings on Amazon.co.jp carry a mandatory prefix such as 【第2類医薬品】 or 【第3類医薬品】. That is a legal display, not seller marketing. The three live listings I verified were titled 「【第2類医薬品】サンテFX Vプラス 12mL」, 「【第2類医薬品】サンテFX AL 12mL ×2」 and 「【第3類医薬品】サンテFX コンタクト 12mL ×6」. You see the risk tier in the search results without opening anything — a genuine convenience of buying medicine on the Japan site, one that has no equivalent on the US site.
Second, compute the per-bottle price. For the same 12mL コンタクト, the six-pack page showed ¥1,680 at capture time, or 280 yen a bottle. The two-pack page showed ¥5,940, or 2,970 yen a bottle. That is more than a tenfold spread, and it comes from third-party sellers setting their own prices. Amazon.co.jp lists both manufacturer stock and marketplace stock, so prices are not uniform. Divide before you buy. The multi-pack page is コンタクト 12mL ×2 and the single is コンタクト 12mL; put them side by side.
Third, know where the evidence stops. The plan named サンテFX ネオ as a target. I ran four different keyword searches on Amazon.co.jp and never got a live listing for it; every search kept returning Vプラス at the top instead. By my own rule, a model whose listing title I cannot parse does not go into the recommendations — which is why the links above cover Vプラス, AL and コンタクト but not ネオ. For ネオ, check Santen's own product page for current availability, or buy it in a Japanese drugstore. This is not an omission; the SKU is simply not findable on the Japan site right now.
On prices and stock: every yen figure here is what the page displayed when I captured it on 5 November 2026. My connection exits in mainland China, so the currency and availability Amazon shows can vary by visitor location, and the checkout page is authoritative. Medicine is a controlled import category in most countries, and personal-use quantities are treated differently from commercial imports. Check your own customs and drug-regulator rules before ordering across a border — that part genuinely varies by country and I cannot vouch for it on your behalf.
FAQ
Is 3rd class weaker? No. The definition is about how much harm the ingredients could plausibly do. コンタクト sits in 3rd class because it drops the vasoconstrictor, the antihistamine and the anticholinesterase, making it the most conservative formula of the four — not because its effect was reduced.
Can I use FX with soft contact lenses? Only コンタクト lists soft lens wear in its indications; the other three cover hard lenses only. Anyone wearing colour contacts cannot use any of the four, and the manufacturer says so explicitly.
How many times a day is too many? By each bottle's own dosing column: 5–6 times for Vプラス, 4–6 for AL, 5–6 for コンタクト, counted per dose. Beyond that, or a week of use with no improvement, means an ophthalmologist rather than another drop.
Which brings it back to the opening point. The hard part of this labelling system is not the Japanese; it is that risk and strength were split into two unrelated fields. Chill is a subjective in-house ranking. The risk tier is a legal classification that decides who may sell the bottle, whether anyone has to explain it, and whether you can dose with lenses in. Remember to look for that one line about discomfort while wearing contact lenses and the choice between the four bottles takes thirty seconds. What actually takes time is the arithmetic — on Amazon.co.jp the price spread on one identical bottle can be wider than the difference between the products themselves.
👉 Join Xiaomi MiMo Platform: Leading AI model platform with cost-effective inference
👉 Join Aliyun AI: Top AI products with exclusive coupons for business innovation
📌 This article was AI-assisted generated and human-reviewed | TechPassive — An AI-driven content testing site focused on real tool reviews
🔗 Recommended Tools
These are carefully selected tools. Using our affiliate links supports us to keep producing quality content:
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.