← Back to Home

Chip Quik Removal Alloy: 58°C vs 79-91°C, Two Kits

removal alloyChip QuikPCB rework

The number that gets misread in desoldering work is rarely the iron setting. It is the little block of alloy in your hand: how low is "low temperature", actually. I did not buy anything for this piece and I do not own a hot plate or a thermocouple. What I did was open each relevant product page on the Chip Quik store, copy the melting-point field verbatim, then check the live Amazon listings to see whether the title, alloy and included accessories describe the same object.

Disclosure first: this article contains Amazon affiliate links, and I earn a commission if you order through them. The price you pay does not change. Wherever I write "the official spec says", I mean the literal line on the manufacturer's product page. Wherever I write "I checked", I mean field-by-field comparison between two pages, not a measurement.

// FLOW_01Four questions before you desolder: board, temperature, resi6 NODES01STEP_01- Does the board require lead-free / RoHS02STEP_02- Yes03STEP_03lead-free alloy, 79-91°C04STEP_04- No05STEP_05leaded alloy, 58°C06STEP_06- Need a new joint afterEND_OF_FLOW
Four questions before you desolder: board, temperature, resi · diagram drawn from this article

One box, two melting points, both printed by the maker

The Chip Quik store page for SMD1 carries exactly one temperature line: "Chip Quik Alloy Melting Point: 58 Celsius (136 F)". The lead-free sibling, SMD1NL, replaces that line with "Chip Quik Lead-Free Alloy Melting Point: 79-91 Celsius (174-195 F)", and the description adds "Same as the SMD1 but with Lead-Free Chip Quik Alloy".

Same page layout, same accessory list, same SMD291 flux in the box. Only the alloy changes. And when it changes, the melting point moves from 58 to a 79-91 range: 21°C higher at the start, 33°C higher at the end.

TL;DR: ① 58°C is the melting point of the leaded removal alloy; 79-91°C is the lead-free version. Same kit, two versions, 21-33°C apart. ② 58 is a point, 79-91 is a range 12°C wide. The same vendor writes "eutectic" explicitly on its 138°C paste, so the distinction is not lost on them. ③ The 138°C SMDLTLFP is not a removal alloy. It is a solder paste, Sn42/Bi57.6/Ag0.4, 87% metal by weight, and it is meant to stay on the board. ④ The lead-free kit costs exactly $1 more ($17 vs $16). What you buy for that dollar is compliance, paid for with a higher and wider melt. ⑤ SRA's competing FAST CHIP page says only "same alloy as the leading brand, lower cost" and gives neither melting point nor composition — readable for price, useless for temperature.

58 is a point. 79-91 is a range.

Whether a melting point is written as a single number or a span is not a typesetting choice. It is the shape of the alloy. A single number means the solidus and liquidus coincide: the alloy goes from solid to liquid at that one temperature, which is what eutectic means. A span means the two lines separate, and inside those 12°C the alloy sits half-solid.

The vendor knows the difference well enough to print "Melts 138C 281F eutectic" on the paste page. On the two removal-alloy pages it gives 58 for one and 79-91 for the other, with no explanation of why one is a point and the other a span.

The practical consequence is one sentence long: with the lead-free alloy, "starts to soften" and "fully liquid" are not the same moment. If you wait the way you wait with the leaded version, at 79°C the alloy has already gone soft but still has the rest of a 12°C mushy zone to cross. Push a component inside that window and the joint tends to string out instead of releasing.

One caveat worth stating plainly: the Chip Quik pages give no recommended iron temperature or dwell time for the removal alloys. I am not inventing one. That is a gap in the evidence, and I would rather name it than write around it.

The 138°C product is a solder, not a removal alloy

SMDLTLFP has an entirely different spec block: Alloy Sn42/Bi57.6/Ag0.4, Flux Type Synthetic No-Clean, Metal Content 87% metal by weight, Particle Size T3 (25-45 microns), Melting Point 138C (281F), Size 5cc/15g syringe. The same page states the shelf life: more than 6 months refrigerated, more than 2 months unrefrigerated.

The dividing line between this and a removal alloy is not temperature. It is whether the joint is meant to survive. The vendor files it as Solder Paste, with the intended use written as soldering surface-mount components to a PCB. Removal alloy lives under SMD Removal Kit, and the kit ships with alcohol pads.

There is a pricing detail that is easy to miss. The same paste is sold as a 10cc/20g T5 version at 67% metal content for $39.50, which works out to roughly $1.98 per gram, against $1.06 per gram for the 87% version at $15.95 for 15g. Twenty percentage points of metal content is a large difference in flux volume, and neither version's page publishes a recommended reflow profile.

Chip Quik SMD1: 58°C is why this box sells

The official kit is 2.5 ft of alloy plus SMD291 tack flux plus alcohol pads, at $16.00 (at the time of writing). Melting point 58°C (136°F). Shelf life appears in two separate lines: more than 24 months refrigerated, more than 24 months unrefrigerated.

The weakness is printed on the label. This is a leaded alloy, and the page carries a California Prop 65 warning verbatim: "This product can expose you to Lead, which is known to the State of California to cause Cancer, Birth Defects, or other Reproductive Harm." For reworking a board that has to be lead-free, this is the easier alloy thermally and the harder one legally.

The listing is here, and its title spells out all three accessories: 2.5ft., flux, alcohol pads. You can tell what is in the box from the title alone.

Chip Quik SMD1 removal alloy kit official product photo main view
Chip Quik SMD1 removal alloy kit official product photo main view · Image source: official product page / brand media
Chip Quik SMD1 removal alloy kit official product photo detail 1
Chip Quik SMD1 removal alloy kit official product photo detail 1 · Image source: official product page / brand media

Chip Quik SMD1NL: same box, melting point becomes 79-91°C

Official price $17.00, one dollar above the leaded kit, with three compliance lines at the top of the page: Lead-Free / RoHS 3 Compliant / REACH Compliant. Accessories, flux and packaging match SMD1.

The weakness is the range itself. It starts melting at 79°C and finishes at 91°C, and there is no second product in the family to compare that 12°C width against, because the leaded version publishes a single number. Whatever operating difference you hit on the lead-free kit cannot be validated by switching brands. And the word "lead-free" is not a synonym for "cold": a 79°C start sits 21°C above the leaded version, near the tolerance edge of many heat-sensitive parts.

The listing is here.

Chip Quik SMD1NL lead-free removal alloy kit official product photo main view
Chip Quik SMD1NL lead-free removal alloy kit official product photo main view · Image source: official product page / brand media
Chip Quik SMD1NL lead-free removal alloy kit official product photo detail 1
Chip Quik SMD1NL lead-free removal alloy kit official product photo detail 1 · Image source: official product page / brand media

Chip Quik SMDLTLFP: a 138°C paste that is allowed to stay

Official price $15.95 for a 5cc / 15g syringe, T3 particle size 25-45 microns, 87% metal content, eutectic at 138°C.

The weakness is that the handling requirements are stricter than for a removal alloy. The vendor requires refrigeration at 3-8°C (37-46°F), no freezing, and the paste must be brought to 20-25°C before use, which takes four hours. Shelf life shrinks accordingly: more than 6 months refrigerated, more than 2 months at room temperature. A 15g syringe has a much shorter usable window than a length of alloy.

The listing is here, and the title states 138C 281F directly.

Chip Quik SMDLTLFP low temperature solder paste official product photo main view
Chip Quik SMDLTLFP low temperature solder paste official product photo main view · Image source: official product page / brand media

Chip Quik SMD291: the flux is what actually decides the outcome

This is the flux that ships inside the kits: SMD291 tack flux no-clean. The 10cc syringe lists at $15.95; the 75g jar, SMD29175G, lists at $63.95 with a stated Flux Classification of REL0 and Synthetic No-Clean.

The weakness is inconsistent fields across package sizes of the same family. The 75g jar page states REL0; the 10cc syringe page does not carry that line at all. What does carry REL0 are the -10M / -5M / NL variants at $11.95 and $9.95. Separately, "no clean" is not the same as "no residue": the vendor publishes no residue figure and no cleaning guidance beyond noting that manual cleaning uses isopropyl alcohol.

The listing is here.

Chip Quik SMD291 no-clean tack flux official product photo main view
Chip Quik SMD291 no-clean tack flux official product photo main view · Image source: official product page / brand media

SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft: the competitor page skips the melting point

SRA Soldering Products publishes this much: 4.5 ft of alloy, supplied as 8 pieces of 6.5 inches with instructions; "Fast Chip Removal Alloy uses the same alloy as the leading brand but is sold at a lower cost"; "No shelf life!". Official price $21.00.

The weakness is blunt: no melting point, no composition, no alloy designation. "Same alloy as the leading brand" is the vendor's own claim, unverified by any third party, and the leading brand is not named. Pages like this are readable for price and unreadable for temperature. If your board sits between 58 and 79, it will not answer your question.

The listing is here. The Amazon title only says "Removal Alloy for SMD Rework - 4.5 ft.", and the material field says Tin.

SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo main view
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo main view · Image source: official product page / brand media
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 1
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 1 · Image source: official product page / brand media
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 2
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 2 · Image source: official product page / brand media
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 3
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 3 · Image source: official product page / brand media
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 4
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 4 · Image source: official product page / brand media
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 5
SRA FAST CHIP 4.5 ft removal alloy official product photo detail 5 · Image source: official product page / brand media

Decision tree: three boards, three temperatures

The earlier piece on solder wire specs already covered the official figures for eutectic Sn63Pb37 at 183°C and SAC305 at 217-220°C, so I will not repeat them here. What this article adds is the layer underneath: why a removal alloy can sit more than a hundred degrees below those numbers. It was never meant to become a joint.

The division of labour between wick and pump is covered in the desoldering wick article and the desoldering pump article: one absorbs, one extracts, and the alloy's job is to turn the joint liquid first.

Five checks before you order

FAQ

Q: Can the 58°C alloy be used as solder?

No. The vendor files it under SMD Removal Kit and names it "Alloy for SMD Removal". Solder is the Solder Paste line, for example the 138°C eutectic SMDLTLFP.

Q: Does a lead-free board require a lead-free removal alloy?

For compliance, yes. For temperature, not necessarily. SMD1NL is specified at 79-91°C, 21-33°C above the leaded kit. If your components cannot take that window, the problem to solve is thermal budget, not alloy choice.

Q: For a 79-91°C range, which number do I set the iron to?

The official page gives no recommended iron temperature for removal alloys, so there is no number to copy. What can be confirmed is narrower: at 79°C the alloy is not fully liquid yet.

Q: Can the 138°C paste replace a removal alloy?

Different jobs. Paste puts a component on; removal alloy takes one off. The paste's residue is meant to stay, while the removal kit ships with alcohol pads.

Q: Why is the gap between the leaded and lead-free kits only one dollar?

The two official pages differ in one line: the alloy. Accessories, flux and packaging are identical, so the difference is basically alloy cost. Where price really separates is specification: the 67% metal, 20g version of the same paste is $39.50.

Boundaries and disclosures

👉 Join Xiaomi MiMo Platform: Leading AI model platform with cost-effective inference

👉 Join Aliyun AI: Top AI products with exclusive coupons for business innovation

📌 This article was AI-assisted generated and human-reviewed | TechPassive — An AI-driven content testing site focused on real tool reviews

🔗 Recommended Tools

These are carefully selected tools. Using our affiliate links supports us to keep producing quality content:

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

☁️ DigitalOcean Cloud ⚡ Vultr VPS 🤖 QoderWork CN (Refer & Earn) ☁️ Aliyun AI Products 📚 WordPress Books 🧠 AI & LLM Books 🏗️ System Design Books 🐳 Docker & K8s Books 🐧 Linux Admin Books 🐍 Python Books 🗄️ Database Books 🚀 DevOps & SRE Books 🤖 Xiaomi MiMo Platform
← Back to Home